Daily Times - Site Edition: "Expert’s proposed constitutional remedy for Balochistan
Staff Report
KARACHI: Failure to revise the concurrent list of the of the Constitution that determines the quantum of provincial autonomy is the cause of unrest in the smaller provinces, especially Balochistan, the president of the Sindh High Court Bar Association, Akhtar Hussain, said on Thursday.
Talking to Daily Times, he said when the Constitution was made in 1973, it was announced the concurrent list determining the quantum of provincial autonomy would be revised after every 10 years. But this was never done, and that lapse happens to be one of the major causes of unrest in the smaller provinces, Mr Hussain said. “Provincial autonomy is meaningless if the province is not autonomous financially,” he remarked.
“It was essentially lack of financial autonomy that led to disenchantment in East Pakistan in 1971, leading to the creation of Bangladesh,” he said. “There have been instances, for example, in the former Soviet Union when self-determination and even the right to secede was ensured in the constitution and the Soviet republics were free to engage in international trading,” he said.
“Therefore, not a single bullet was fired when these republics opted for independence,” he said. “Nobody should be opposed to development projects like the Gwadar Deep Sea Port,” Mr Hussain said. “But the unskilled labour force in such projects should be absorbed from the local population, and vocational institutions established in Balochistan to provide skill to the local population,” he proposed.
He admitted there would be an influx of skilled workers from other provinces during the development process in Balochistan. But he said these people “should not have the right to vote in Balochistan, and this would remove the apprehensions of the locals that they would become a minority in their own province,” he said. But Barrister Qazi Faez Isa, an advocate of the Supreme Court, blamed the sardars, calling them “the curse of Balochistan.” “They don’t represent Balochistan at all,” he declared. “They kill their own people; they don’t want their people in power.” He reminded the sardari system had been abolished in 1975 and said that for someone to claim to be a sardar is illegal. But he complained that “even the present chief minister of Balochistan (Jam Mir Yusuf) is a sardar.”
Every sardar is a parasite, since he does not work for a living, Mr Isa said.
“They killed Justice Nawaz Mari in cold blood. He would have become chief justice of Balochistan, which was intolerable for them,” according to Mr Isa.
Hard-line Baloch leader Nawab Akbar Bugti “is a convicted murderer, which he admits,” he maintained. “Balochistan’s natural resources do not belong to Mr Bugti, they belong to the people of Balochistan,” Mr Isa declared.“In fact, the curse of Balochistan are the sardars.” He further said: “It is unfortunate that PML leader Mushahid Hussain has not spoken to a single doctor, lawyer or hari of Balochistan. Instead he has spoken to sardars. The provincial government in Balochistan is not even able to spend 30 percent of the development budget. How can they ask for more money? The government should disclose the secret funds it has been providing to sardars. These are used for arming the tribal.”
In an exclusive interview with Daily Times last week, president Pakistan Oppressed Nations Movement (PONM) Sardar Ataullah Mengal said Balochistan should have the right to utilise its huge natural resources. With an area of 3,47, 188, square km that is larger than the combined area of Punjab and Sindh, Balochistan comprises 44 percent of Pakistan, has an 800 km long coastline, produces 36 percent if natural gas, according to data compiled by PONM. The province has immense geo-strategic importance since it is hub between South Asia, South West Asia (Middle East) and Central Asia; it shares 1173 km long border with Iranian Balochistan, and 837 km long border with Afghanistan besides having offshore potential of natural resources in Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ).
Balochistan EEZ covers a wide expanse of 1,80000 square km and is located at the heart of main Sea Trade Route. American scholar Selig S. Harrison in his famous book, “In Afghanistan’s Shadow: Baluch Nationalism and Soviet Temptations” published in 1981, said: “A glance at the map quickly explains why strategically located Baluchistan and the five million Baluch tribesmen who live there could easily become the focal point of superpower conflict. Stretching across a vast expanse of western Pakistan and eastern Iran-an area slightly larger than France-the Baluch homeland commands more than 900 miles of the Arabian Sea coastline, including the northern shores of the Strait of Hormuz, through which oil tankers bound for the West and Japan must pass on their way out of the Persian Gulf.”"